DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - What are the good traditional (non-Salafi) Hanbali resources?

**megatrendsZ** · 01-02-2011, 02:26 PM

Why do you quote adh-Dhahabi , and highlight his mention of some people's ascription of ibn Kullab to Christianity, as if it were important information, when adh-Dhahabi himself refuted the idea?

Dhahabi only said "And some of those who do not know said: That he innovated what he innovated in order to [enter and] conceal the religion of the Christians into our religion, and that he pleased his sister by that. And this is false "

So, what is false according to Dhahabi that the accusation of concealing christianity ( taqiya ) but the reality according to al-Dhahabi is what Dhahabi report from Abul Abbas al-Baghawi with the tacit approval ( and not refuting it which means tacit approval ) which is:

Abu al-Abbaas al-Baghawee said: Faythoon the Christian said to me: May Allaah have mercy upon Abdullaah [bin Sa'eed bin Kullaab]. He used to come to me to the Church and would take from me, and if he remained alive, we would have turned the Muslims into Christians. So it was said to Faythoon: What do you say about al-Maseeh [Easaa bin Maryam]? He said: [The same] as what the people of your Sunnah say regarding the Qur'an.

01-02-2011, 02:26 PM	#31
megatrendsZ Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 468 Senior Member	Why do you quote adh-Dhahabi , and highlight his mention of some people's ascription of ibn Kullab to Christianity, as if it were important information, when adh-Dhahabi himself refuted the idea? Dhahabi only said "And some of those who do not know said: That he innovated what he innovated in order to [enter and] conceal the religion of the Christians into our religion, and that he pleased his sister by that. And this is false " So, what is false according to Dhahabi that the accusation of concealing christianity ( taqiya ) but the reality according to al-Dhahabi is what Dhahabi report from Abul Abbas al-Baghawi with the tacit approval ( and not refuting it which means tacit approval ) which is: Abu al-Abbaas al-Baghawee said: Faythoon the Christian said to me: May Allaah have mercy upon Abdullaah [bin Sa'eed bin Kullaab]. He used to come to me to the Church and would take from me, and if he remained alive, we would have turned the Muslims into Christians. So it was said to Faythoon: What do you say about al-Maseeh [Easaa bin Maryam]? He said: [The same] as what the people of your Sunnah say regarding the Qur'an.
	Quote