DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Muslim sister be friends with Muslim brother strictly platonic

**SallyIsNice5** · 10-11-2011, 05:14 AM

I agree, some of the responses here have been disgusting, "not so platonic" I shivered when I read this. If Muslims cant come to other Muslims for advice without being called names etc is it any wonder our confused children go to their non-Muslim friends for advice. At least they wont be so bloody insensitive. They drag them to hell while being nice and giving liberal modern advice and we call to heaven by calling people trolls and making fun of their question. No wonder we went from an Islamic state to the sorry state we are in now.

If the OP is a genuine person with a problem, then the view that it is platonic is only in her head. It is not an accusation towards her; she merely has a misunderstanding. If she believes the guy would get suicidal, then that means that the relationship is NOT platonic - at least to him.

Plus, platonic relationships are still not allowed in Islam.

10-11-2011, 05:14 AM	#14
SallyIsNice5 Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 553 Senior Member	I agree, some of the responses here have been disgusting, "not so platonic" I shivered when I read this. If Muslims cant come to other Muslims for advice without being called names etc is it any wonder our confused children go to their non-Muslim friends for advice. At least they wont be so bloody insensitive. They drag them to hell while being nice and giving liberal modern advice and we call to heaven by calling people trolls and making fun of their question. No wonder we went from an Islamic state to the sorry state we are in now. If the OP is a genuine person with a problem, then the view that it is platonic is only in her head. It is not an accusation towards her; she merely has a misunderstanding. If she believes the guy would get suicidal, then that means that the relationship is NOT platonic - at least to him. Plus, platonic relationships are still not allowed in Islam.
	Quote