DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Answer to a Barelwi regarding kissing thumbs during athan!

**Dndjzirw** · 11-24-2010, 06:50 PM

FA doesnt say to do any action like do push up 20 time after prayer, you will get reward for this weak hadith!

its about an action which has been introduced via weak hadith, and not the amount of the virtue.

in FA all weak hadith are related with sahih hadith and only differes amount of virtue, and not introducing any specific action like kiss this and wipe that. this is related wit fiqh, and no action is allowed which is based upon weak hadith. which is already cleared by bro abuhajira.

ok then tell it to sh Afif, its clear what his opinion is based on ijtihad by the shafi method. are you telling me that you hanafis know the shafi method of usool better that a scholar from the shafi madhab. like he said it still doesnt make it haraam either

11-24-2010, 06:50 PM	#24
Dndjzirw Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 535 Senior Member	FA doesnt say to do any action like do push up 20 time after prayer, you will get reward for this weak hadith! its about an action which has been introduced via weak hadith, and not the amount of the virtue. in FA all weak hadith are related with sahih hadith and only differes amount of virtue, and not introducing any specific action like kiss this and wipe that. this is related wit fiqh, and no action is allowed which is based upon weak hadith. which is already cleared by bro abuhajira. ok then tell it to sh Afif, its clear what his opinion is based on ijtihad by the shafi method. are you telling me that you hanafis know the shafi method of usool better that a scholar from the shafi madhab. like he said it still doesnt make it haraam either
	Quote