[Wezfyowk]

I was going to say that it is only for the one who makes the calculation & fasting would become waajib for him only. So in Imaam Ramli's view as soon as the moon is born & you are able to calculate then it is wajib for you to fast? this is a question sorry. Yes, according to al-Ramli and his father, rahimahuma Allah, its wajib for the astronomer and the one who believes him.

Is Imam Ramli the only one of the shawafi with this view...... so in Egypt where Imam Ramli is followed do the practice this. ......
most Shafi' follow ibn Hajar so maybe that is why we work with sighting though. I dont know if anyone else except for al-Ramli and his father holds the view that its wajib. But Ibn al-Rif'a, al-Zarkashi and al-Subki say that its valid to fast reliying on calculations (Bughyat al-Mustarshidin)