DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The Majlis: HILAAL DETERMINATIONS OF SAUDI ARABIA NOT VALID

**CreativeAcrobate** · 08-24-2011, 12:52 AM

Salam Alaikum,

The brother said the website above is anti-Salafi so we shouldn't rely on it.

lol do you know who the brother is? is the brother an authority of the deen? are you going to take something from a random person on the internet without any proof and base a decision on this?

the majlisul ulama are known and respected by many members on this forum and also by ulama throughout the world.

We should end Ramadan and Celebrate with Saudi Arabia.

why? there is no such criteria in the deen. if there is then please tell me as i do not know about it.

Great scholars of Saudi are involved in this so how can you say it is Haram.

which scholars? which part are you referring to not being haram?

A great Phd scholar, graduate of al-Azhar also said the same thing that it is better to follow Saudi Arabia.

which one? what is his name?

08-24-2011, 12:52 AM	#21
CreativeAcrobate Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 407 Senior Member	Salam Alaikum, The brother said the website above is anti-Salafi so we shouldn't rely on it. lol do you know who the brother is? is the brother an authority of the deen? are you going to take something from a random person on the internet without any proof and base a decision on this? the majlisul ulama are known and respected by many members on this forum and also by ulama throughout the world. We should end Ramadan and Celebrate with Saudi Arabia. why? there is no such criteria in the deen. if there is then please tell me as i do not know about it. Great scholars of Saudi are involved in this so how can you say it is Haram. which scholars? which part are you referring to not being haram? A great Phd scholar, graduate of al-Azhar also said the same thing that it is better to follow Saudi Arabia. which one? what is his name?
	Quote