[attishina]

Due to time restraints and a major university deadline, inshAllah i will restrict myself to this thread. As noone seems to ever read through the resources I provide, inshAllah I myself will read through them and then have a discussion on bid'ah here inshAllah and the thread is open for all those who wish to join in inshAllah.

I will start by refuting the issue of whether the shaafi madhab allows bid'ah hasanah inshAllah.

Now can someone prove to me that the classical shaafi jurists approved of innovating any act of worship that you want into the shariah? If not, please explain what you think the jurists meant by bid'a hasanah, what its rules and regulations are, where its boundaries are, and some examples of accepted and unnacceptable bid'ah.

Please note that I am asking for a discussion, not articles, I am not interested and iwll not read articles as noone else seems to bother reading any articles I provide.

bring your proofs and I wil bring my proofs and inshAllah we will establish teh haqh.

Brother tripoly I believe the shaafi madhab doesnt approve of bid'ah so please let me demonstrate this to you inshAllah. Also Colonel Hardstone. Dont just blindly follow the statement of your contomorary scholars who say the shaafi madhab allows it, let u look into the matter and find out inshAllah.

Which repsectable classical scholars allowed bid'ah?

Do you all believe imam nawawi allowed bid'ah?