DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**seosoftseo** · 04-18-2011, 05:53 AM

Then why didn't Bukhari dispose of this "hadith"? And what about the others I listed (theres many more)?

Infact Dr Shabbir has helped you already by gathering all such Hadiths in a book and they mount upto 150 ( Half of them are sayings of the jurists which he has termed Hadiths). Picking out 150 narration out the tens of thousands of Hadiths and objecting them on the basis of " they don't match my mind" is illogical.
Why would Bukhari dispose off this hadith? Hadith is a record of our history and its a specialized record unlike the common history books. We can expand it if you are interested in discussing it but Dr springer , the famous German orientalist summarizes it this way.
"There has been no nation in the world ever which has invented the science of Isma wa Rijal(hadith sciences) like Muslims , due to which the record of 5 lac narrators is preserved"

I would go through the rest of Hadiths mentioned by you and would try to provide you the explanations.

04-18-2011, 05:53 AM	#22
seosoftseo Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 597 Senior Member	Then why didn't Bukhari dispose of this "hadith"? And what about the others I listed (theres many more)? Infact Dr Shabbir has helped you already by gathering all such Hadiths in a book and they mount upto 150 ( Half of them are sayings of the jurists which he has termed Hadiths). Picking out 150 narration out the tens of thousands of Hadiths and objecting them on the basis of " they don't match my mind" is illogical. Why would Bukhari dispose off this hadith? Hadith is a record of our history and its a specialized record unlike the common history books. We can expand it if you are interested in discussing it but Dr springer , the famous German orientalist summarizes it this way. "There has been no nation in the world ever which has invented the science of Isma wa Rijal(hadith sciences) like Muslims , due to which the record of 5 lac narrators is preserved" I would go through the rest of Hadiths mentioned by you and would try to provide you the explanations.
	Quote