DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**SeftyJokipl** · 07-29-2011, 09:11 PM

Firstly i would just like to say this is not a thread to bash salafis/ahle-hadith

I am just wondering why they are referred to as ghair muqallids by others?
To me they are not really ghair muqallids. They may not follow one of the 4 madhabs in their entirety but they do make taqleed of scholars else i would imagine they would all pray differently and all come up with different opinions but for the most part they all seem to follow the same rulings on fiqhi issues

so are they really ghair muqallids?

In one the audio file of Mufti Saeed Ahmed Palanpuri D.B I was listening, Mufti Sahib Said (not-exact words) In fact these Ahle-hadith / salafi people are not Ghair-muqallid, they are also Muqallids. They refer and accept the view of the scholars of their group only, where as the Sholars of a Madhab refer and view opinions of other madhabs. Thus these Ahle Hadith / Salafess are much greater Muqallid than us.

07-29-2011, 09:11 PM	#2
SeftyJokipl Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 501 Senior Member	Firstly i would just like to say this is not a thread to bash salafis/ahle-hadith I am just wondering why they are referred to as ghair muqallids by others? To me they are not really ghair muqallids. They may not follow one of the 4 madhabs in their entirety but they do make taqleed of scholars else i would imagine they would all pray differently and all come up with different opinions but for the most part they all seem to follow the same rulings on fiqhi issues so are they really ghair muqallids? In one the audio file of Mufti Saeed Ahmed Palanpuri D.B I was listening, Mufti Sahib Said (not-exact words) In fact these Ahle-hadith / salafi people are not Ghair-muqallid, they are also Muqallids. They refer and accept the view of the scholars of their group only, where as the Sholars of a Madhab refer and view opinions of other madhabs. Thus these Ahle Hadith / Salafess are much greater Muqallid than us.
	Quote