View Single Post
Old 07-28-2011, 07:17 PM   #16
Master_B

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
428
Senior Member
Default
Dear Brother David.(Dawud Beale) is there is any problem to follow all four imam's ? is there is any compulsory to follow only one ? pls answer me.
Wa alaykum salaam bro. I dont consider it waajib to follow madhab, as long as you aren tfollowing your desires and are staying within the oppinions of the salaf. However I consider it to be better to follow madhab due to the difficulties of studying fiqh without a madhab. I simply consider you to be making life harder for yourself by not studying a madhab, but as long as all your oppinions are valid then no problem. If the so called madhabis in your area are into extreme shirk and whatnot it is understandable if you prefer to stick to what can be proven in qur'an and hadeeth. As long as you respect people who follow mainly the oppinsion of abu hanfiah and his school and the others schoolas too and dont attack them for it.

As for the guy who claims hijab isnt wajib (If thats what he menat) then this is a different kettle of fish, this oppinion isnt only restricted to one madhab, there is no one from the salat that I have ever herad of that said hijab wasnt wajib. This means there is ijma sakuuwti, the whole ummmah gathered upon this, so to say this is kufr. If he steps outside the oppinions of the salaf he's in trouble to be honest.

Also to say he only accepts hadeeths from bukhari and muslim is not correct either and no scholar says that, he is coming up with things himself.

However, I suspect its because he hasnt got a lot of knowledge and inshAllah as he studies, these issues will become clear to him.

Mya dvice, dont bother about the madhab issue. But definitely advise him on any issue that is outside the views of the salaf. The issue of hijab you must change his oppinion on this because he may be committing kufr
Master_B is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:57 AM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity