DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Master_B** · 07-28-2011, 11:23 PM

sisterb you shouldnt use analogies liike this to compare the deen.

your analogy is flawed anyhow dears sister.

Is there anything wrong with me asking one doctor about my headache and then asking another doctor about my saw throat?

Is there any harm me asking one doctor about how safe a medicatio is and then asking another doctor. Its what we call in england a second oppinion

By your thinking, when Im ill, I must always go to the same doctor, ask him for medication, then take whatever he gives me, no questions asked, and for me to even do my own research on the medicine he gave me is heavily sinful because Im not medically trained and he is.

All Im saying is, madhabs are very useful, but you cant use analogies of doctors to make it obligatory on someone to follow.

07-28-2011, 11:23 PM	#23
Master_B Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 428 Senior Member	sisterb you shouldnt use analogies liike this to compare the deen. your analogy is flawed anyhow dears sister. Is there anything wrong with me asking one doctor about my headache and then asking another doctor about my saw throat? Is there any harm me asking one doctor about how safe a medicatio is and then asking another doctor. Its what we call in england a second oppinion By your thinking, when Im ill, I must always go to the same doctor, ask him for medication, then take whatever he gives me, no questions asked, and for me to even do my own research on the medicine he gave me is heavily sinful because Im not medically trained and he is. All Im saying is, madhabs are very useful, but you cant use analogies of doctors to make it obligatory on someone to follow.
	Quote