DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The narration from Hadrat Ali (ra) for placing hands under the navel?

**deethythitoth** · 01-02-2008, 11:53 PM

I don't think you will find exact expressions of ta'dil from Tirmidhi and Hakim nor al-Ijli. But, where does Suyuti make tawthiq on him except that he quoted Ibn hajar's qawl al-musaddad that Tirmidhi considered some of his narrations to be Hasan, while Hakim and Ibn Khuzayma had one narration via him though he had some issues with him still...

Shukran

i think your right, but one way or another they accepted him because they still narrated his hadith and qualified them as hasan and Sahih even knowing the issues surrounding him...that tells us something

regarding imam Ijli, Shakyh Riyad-ul Haq said in his book something regarding him...i dont know the exact quote, maybe you might know it.

iv seen a similar fatwa on askimam.org where Mufti Ebrahim Desai quotes Imam Bazzaar and Ijli saying it is permissible to use his hadiths.

Allah knows best

01-02-2008, 11:53 PM	#12
deethythitoth Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 382 Senior Member	I don't think you will find exact expressions of ta'dil from Tirmidhi and Hakim nor al-Ijli. But, where does Suyuti make tawthiq on him except that he quoted Ibn hajar's qawl al-musaddad that Tirmidhi considered some of his narrations to be Hasan, while Hakim and Ibn Khuzayma had one narration via him though he had some issues with him still... Shukran i think your right, but one way or another they accepted him because they still narrated his hadith and qualified them as hasan and Sahih even knowing the issues surrounding him...that tells us something regarding imam Ijli, Shakyh Riyad-ul Haq said in his book something regarding him...i dont know the exact quote, maybe you might know it. iv seen a similar fatwa on askimam.org where Mufti Ebrahim Desai quotes Imam Bazzaar and Ijli saying it is permissible to use his hadiths. Allah knows best
	Quote