DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - The narration from Hadrat Ali (ra) for placing hands under the navel?

**WeestDype** · 01-06-2008, 09:11 AM

assalamualaykum

brother i have read riadh ul-haq's book and personally i dont agree with alot of his opinions and you should read of some of his extreme opinions never mind about his book.Anyway ive told you my opinion and i know yours so lets stop whats the point we should look at our own selves we are all muslims here alhamdulillah and we are bickering so lets show the character of a muslim that for the sake of allah the minor issue is left aside and the major issue is being implimented ie. unity.

So please we have our opinions alhamdulillah and we have our proofs but just push this aside and concentrate on unity inshallah.

Asslamo Allaikum Respected Brother,

Ajeeb!

1) First you attacked the Hanafi position

2) Then you tryed to defend the narrations about placing the hands on the chest and came up with the absurd combinaton of Shaykh Al-Albani (RA) & Fiqhus-Sunna...I have placed my comments on a public forum with the name of the book and translation of Shaykh Al-Albani (RA)'s book about Fiqhus-Sunnah, you or anyone else is free to google it.

The other objections to Shaykh Al-Albani (RA) are also in public and you or anyone else is free to google it.

Please note that I have not used any Sufi sources in any of my discussion to you.

3) When you couldn't prove/back-up either you came up with a "unity plan"

4) Then you object to "many things" of Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq and try to broaden the scope of the discussion which is beyond this thread

I love you for the sake of Allah (SWT), I spoke to another brother years ago who also objected to "many things" of Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq...

My advice to him was, "I have Shaykh's Mobile (Cell-Phone for Americans/Canadians

); lets go see him and present your objections to him & about the book personally" and let him answer it...That way you will be saved from Gheeba and you will give him a chance to reply as it is only fair...

The brother never spoke about this matter again but fortunately he is now a Hanafi like many "Salafees" of early & late ninetees.

Please call your friends and scholars and lets go see Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq and give him a chance to answer your queries; he is a kind, hospitable and poliet person and has no aversions to meeting anyone.

None of this is meant as a disrespect to you in anyway whatso-ever, Insha'Allah.

All you are asked is speak from Qur'aan & Sunnah and with evidence and refrain from generalisations.

01-06-2008, 09:11 AM	#39
WeestDype Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 453 Senior Member	assalamualaykum brother i have read riadh ul-haq's book and personally i dont agree with alot of his opinions and you should read of some of his extreme opinions never mind about his book.Anyway ive told you my opinion and i know yours so lets stop whats the point we should look at our own selves we are all muslims here alhamdulillah and we are bickering so lets show the character of a muslim that for the sake of allah the minor issue is left aside and the major issue is being implimented ie. unity. So please we have our opinions alhamdulillah and we have our proofs but just push this aside and concentrate on unity inshallah. Asslamo Allaikum Respected Brother, Ajeeb! 1) First you attacked the Hanafi position 2) Then you tryed to defend the narrations about placing the hands on the chest and came up with the absurd combinaton of Shaykh Al-Albani (RA) & Fiqhus-Sunna...I have placed my comments on a public forum with the name of the book and translation of Shaykh Al-Albani (RA)'s book about Fiqhus-Sunnah, you or anyone else is free to google it. The other objections to Shaykh Al-Albani (RA) are also in public and you or anyone else is free to google it. Please note that I have not used any Sufi sources in any of my discussion to you. 3) When you couldn't prove/back-up either you came up with a "unity plan" 4) Then you object to "many things" of Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq and try to broaden the scope of the discussion which is beyond this thread I love you for the sake of Allah (SWT), I spoke to another brother years ago who also objected to "many things" of Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq... My advice to him was, "I have Shaykh's Mobile (Cell-Phone for Americans/Canadians ); lets go see him and present your objections to him & about the book personally" and let him answer it...That way you will be saved from Gheeba and you will give him a chance to reply as it is only fair... The brother never spoke about this matter again but fortunately he is now a Hanafi like many "Salafees" of early & late ninetees. Please call your friends and scholars and lets go see Shaykh Riyadhul-Haq and give him a chance to answer your queries; he is a kind, hospitable and poliet person and has no aversions to meeting anyone. None of this is meant as a disrespect to you in anyway whatso-ever, Insha'Allah. All you are asked is speak from Qur'aan & Sunnah and with evidence and refrain from generalisations.
	Quote