DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Squeernemergo** · 07-17-2011, 04:58 PM

oh, i thought nur ul idah was a classical text? Arent the texts u mentioned all contemporary? If its ok id like to stick to classical texts as i cant be sure who is properly following the madhabs from thi day and age for the moment, so id like to learn from the classical scholars inshallah as anyone can claim anything in our times, most of the people who claim a madhab are further away from a madhab than the salafis are ironically. Like those who call themselves hanafi secularists. How can u be hanafi whos a secularist, since when have abu hanifah been a secularist

Assalamu alaikum brother,

I am not saying this in a mocking or derogatory way but what you are saying above shows you need to understand the matter better. I am not going to say more but I hope a scholar can actually give some input at this point. I guarantee you this that there is no book in English which presents the strongest opinions in one place unlike the books I quoted above.

07-17-2011, 04:58 PM	#26
Squeernemergo Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 493 Senior Member	oh, i thought nur ul idah was a classical text? Arent the texts u mentioned all contemporary? If its ok id like to stick to classical texts as i cant be sure who is properly following the madhabs from thi day and age for the moment, so id like to learn from the classical scholars inshallah as anyone can claim anything in our times, most of the people who claim a madhab are further away from a madhab than the salafis are ironically. Like those who call themselves hanafi secularists. How can u be hanafi whos a secularist, since when have abu hanifah been a secularist Assalamu alaikum brother, I am not saying this in a mocking or derogatory way but what you are saying above shows you need to understand the matter better. I am not going to say more but I hope a scholar can actually give some input at this point. I guarantee you this that there is no book in English which presents the strongest opinions in one place unlike the books I quoted above.
	Quote