DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**freeringtonesioo** · 10-06-2010, 06:52 PM

Assalamu'alaikum

Burhanudhin Ibrahim ibn Umar al-Biqaii al Shafii(d.885.AH), a scholar of Tafsir and Hadith had accused them of Kufr but in fact he had been in turn refuted by Imam Jalaludin al-Suyuti(Rah)(d.911..AH), another prominent shafii scholar of repute .[Ref:Shadaratu Zahab by Ibnul Imad al-Hanbali]

In turn, Suyuti was refuted by Ibrahim Al-Halabi Al-Hanafi. By the way, apparently even Suyuti did not have good opinion regarding Ibn Arabi, OR probably he changed his view later on.

Some scholars, especially those Dhahiri scholars(NOT referring to the Fiqhi school) not trained in the inner sciences(tasawwuf), made Takfir of them. The majority of the Sufiyah have praised them, especially Shaykh Al-Akbar Ibn 'Arabi (rahmatu'Allahi 'alayh). His legacy is to be found especially in the Shathili Tariqa.

Oh yes... all those were Zahiris. Faqih Ibn Abdussalaam, Shaikhul Islam Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Iraqi, Dhahabi, Allama Taqi As-Subki, Shaikhul Islam Bulqeeni, Hafiz Ibn Hajar, Sakhawi and so on and so forth, all these were Zahiris ignorant of inner science.

Interestingly, it was Ibn Arabi who was a Zahiri (in fiqh, all though Batini in faith). Izz Ibn Abdussalam got Al-Muhalla from Ibn Arabi.

AOA,

anyways.....ive heard abt the things which are said related to the 2 persons mentioned....all i can say is tht we shud leave it to Allah.....leave it as mutashabihat.....dont make judgements......worry abt ur own self.....Allah will ask abt YOU on YOUR judgement day.....so we shud all get ready for tht........

Wallah Ho Allam

That means leave all those who propagate that Firawn died as Muslim, and people of Bani Israel were correct in worshiping the calf and and Musa (AS) got angry on Harun (AS) because he stopped them from worshiping it.

10-06-2010, 06:52 PM	#22
freeringtonesioo Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 478 Senior Member	Assalamu'alaikum Burhanudhin Ibrahim ibn Umar al-Biqaii al Shafii(d.885.AH), a scholar of Tafsir and Hadith had accused them of Kufr but in fact he had been in turn refuted by Imam Jalaludin al-Suyuti(Rah)(d.911..AH), another prominent shafii scholar of repute .[Ref:Shadaratu Zahab by Ibnul Imad al-Hanbali] In turn, Suyuti was refuted by Ibrahim Al-Halabi Al-Hanafi. By the way, apparently even Suyuti did not have good opinion regarding Ibn Arabi, OR probably he changed his view later on. Some scholars, especially those Dhahiri scholars(NOT referring to the Fiqhi school) not trained in the inner sciences(tasawwuf), made Takfir of them. The majority of the Sufiyah have praised them, especially Shaykh Al-Akbar Ibn 'Arabi (rahmatu'Allahi 'alayh). His legacy is to be found especially in the Shathili Tariqa. Oh yes... all those were Zahiris. Faqih Ibn Abdussalaam, Shaikhul Islam Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Iraqi, Dhahabi, Allama Taqi As-Subki, Shaikhul Islam Bulqeeni, Hafiz Ibn Hajar, Sakhawi and so on and so forth, all these were Zahiris ignorant of inner science. Interestingly, it was Ibn Arabi who was a Zahiri (in fiqh, all though Batini in faith). Izz Ibn Abdussalam got Al-Muhalla from Ibn Arabi. AOA, anyways.....ive heard abt the things which are said related to the 2 persons mentioned....all i can say is tht we shud leave it to Allah.....leave it as mutashabihat.....dont make judgements......worry abt ur own self.....Allah will ask abt YOU on YOUR judgement day.....so we shud all get ready for tht........ Wallah Ho Allam That means leave all those who propagate that Firawn died as Muslim, and people of Bani Israel were correct in worshiping the calf and and Musa (AS) got angry on Harun (AS) because he stopped them from worshiping it.
	Quote