Maybe you misunderstood what I was trying to say. Im not interested in changing your position. You asked a lot of questions and you said that you had an open mind. One of the questions was about al-Qurtubis qiyas. You said that it didn't make any sense (or something similar) You got an answer that showed that the qiyas was valid. After that you didn't want to continue the discussion. If you don't want to discuss thats fine with me, but it's a little bit strange that your honest quest for truth died out after that short discussion don't you think? There have been a lot of people on this forum that have "none" as madhab and they claim to have an open mind and wants to discuss the evidence. As soon as the evidence doesn't point in their direction (i.e. to the salafi position) their open mind is closed. After a short while they disappear from the forum. I honestly hope you don't belong to them.