View Single Post
Old 06-29-2011, 01:13 PM   #19
Teeppoodiug

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
476
Senior Member
Default


I have to disagree with this notion, and it's something that is often trotted out as a reason that Islam and democracy cannot coexist. I've heard so many people say that Muslim cannot have a democratic system of government because people might vote to approve something which is un-Islamic. However, the solution to this is incredibly obvious: make a Constitution that says all newly proposed laws and regulations must abide by the shariah, and have a court system that could strike down laws and regulations that they deem un-Islamic. I just find this whole "oh but they could vote on something and make that which Allah declared haram halal" argument to be absurd. Well...so could any ruler! The difference is that if that ruler does such a thing, within a democratic framework, the people could simply elect him out of office or the courts could simply strike down his laws. In an autocratic system, the leader could do all of these things, and nothing could stop him other than a revolt, which of course is a horrible thing to occur within a country because it leads to economic stagnation and the purging of counter-revolutionaries--or if the revolt fails, simply quite a lot of dead people.
Salam alikum
.. just to say - I agree with your opinion, reading many posts I found your answer very interesting and more less compatible with mines.
I think also state under saria should be based on democracy -it is not about to oppose sharia but to choose more suitable form of sharia. I rely on that as in addition to that in islam is forbiden oppression of minorities of any kind so that it would be an additional issue by any voting. I think it wuold be just another type of democracy - not exactly the same as we wee now in the west, as it would be within sharia - role of sholars should be in high position too, but more as advisory, is some cases decisive - like when establishing courts, proposing law .....
I believe people are still more and more smart, they must learn and take big portion of responsibility, othrewise we can not progress.
I dont say this is my final opinion on subject - jast couple of thoughts

w salam
Teeppoodiug is offline


 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:54 PM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity