DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Proof for asking the Prophet to make dua for you?

**lakraboob** · 06-21-2011, 04:43 AM

I'm seriously wondering did you look at the tafseer or determined what is haqeeqi and what is maajazi by yourself?

Al-Qurtubi mentions a hadeeth narrated by Bukhari and Tirmidhi, which mentions Umar and Abu Bakr conversing in front of the Prophet , and they raised their literal real voices, and this verse was revealed.

He also mentions:

وقد كره بعض العلماء رفع الصوت عند قبره عليه السلام. وكره بعض العلماء رفع الصوت في مجالس العلماء تشريفاً لهم؛ إذ هم ورثة الأنبيا

That some scholars hated for voices to be raised near the Prophets grave, and some of them also hated for it to be in a sitting with scholars, out of respect for them because they are the waratha of the scholars.

He also mentions for ayah 4 a real story of a bedoin entering the Masjid and calling upon the Prophet while he was behind his walls.

So I'm really confused about what you mean exactly?

You are a real politician, aren't you?

Lot of words come out of your mouth but nothing meaningful and you have a habit of not reading but assuming.

Firstly you have cleverly skipped the questions because you can't explain it!

Secondly, How are you assuming that someone is YELLING at the top of the voice or even RAISING their voice?

Where did you get this conversation from?

Lets discuss the figments of your imaginations for 5 days

06-21-2011, 04:43 AM	#20
lakraboob Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 451 Senior Member	I'm seriously wondering did you look at the tafseer or determined what is haqeeqi and what is maajazi by yourself? Al-Qurtubi mentions a hadeeth narrated by Bukhari and Tirmidhi, which mentions Umar and Abu Bakr conversing in front of the Prophet , and they raised their literal real voices, and this verse was revealed. He also mentions: وقد كره بعض العلماء رفع الصوت عند قبره عليه السلام. وكره بعض العلماء رفع الصوت في مجالس العلماء تشريفاً لهم؛ إذ هم ورثة الأنبيا That some scholars hated for voices to be raised near the Prophets grave, and some of them also hated for it to be in a sitting with scholars, out of respect for them because they are the waratha of the scholars. He also mentions for ayah 4 a real story of a bedoin entering the Masjid and calling upon the Prophet while he was behind his walls. So I'm really confused about what you mean exactly? You are a real politician, aren't you? Lot of words come out of your mouth but nothing meaningful and you have a habit of not reading but assuming. Firstly you have cleverly skipped the questions because you can't explain it! Secondly, How are you assuming that someone is YELLING at the top of the voice or even RAISING their voice? Where did you get this conversation from? Lets discuss the figments of your imaginations for 5 days
	Quote