DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**zlopikanikanz** · 06-29-2011, 09:07 PM

,

Truly I hesitated writing this as I'm a nobody to everybody here, let alone past and present 'ulama and do not want to be counted with those who slander imam Ghazzali (). Al-inaam website had an article on this but could not find it otherwise I would have posted it instead.
And concerning this specific issue Mufti taqi Al-'Uthmani (Hafidhahullah) must have analysed all the proofs including the statements of senior 'ulama like Al-Ghazzali (). And to use your argument Sahaba+Tabi'un+Tab'tabi'een>>>>>mutakallimun.

for your concern.

Mufti Taqi has come to a conclusion. But it's not the only conclusion in regards to this issue as clearly demonstrated by al Ghazzali. So those who do extra ibaada on this night in the belief that it is praisworthy cannot be condemned.

And who are the non deobandi and non-salafi scholars who share the same view as them about this night?

06-29-2011, 09:07 PM	#15
zlopikanikanz Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 625 Senior Member	, Truly I hesitated writing this as I'm a nobody to everybody here, let alone past and present 'ulama and do not want to be counted with those who slander imam Ghazzali (). Al-inaam website had an article on this but could not find it otherwise I would have posted it instead. And concerning this specific issue Mufti taqi Al-'Uthmani (Hafidhahullah) must have analysed all the proofs including the statements of senior 'ulama like Al-Ghazzali (). And to use your argument Sahaba+Tabi'un+Tab'tabi'een>>>>>mutakallimun. for your concern. Mufti Taqi has come to a conclusion. But it's not the only conclusion in regards to this issue as clearly demonstrated by al Ghazzali. So those who do extra ibaada on this night in the belief that it is praisworthy cannot be condemned. And who are the non deobandi and non-salafi scholars who share the same view as them about this night?
	Quote