Again generalisation.. ur NOT the only man there to Crow about NOT taking cuts.. Before accusing me of generalization, it would have been better for you to have read bro qibla's post which I answered. Then you would not have falsely accused me of 'again generalizing'. And I am not crowing about not taking cuts. I am trying to start a conversation about cuts, not taking cuts and the effects that this phenomenon has on poor patients, Muslims and otherwise. It is quite an important topic which you have so effectively derailed. if ur saying 100% tableeghi doctors take it.. then it is a Bohtan .. remember that.. u have to answer Allah .. What Qibla wanted to know was whether I was 100% sure that those doctors I mentioned went in Jamaat and took kickbacks as well. So the figure reflected my certainty with reference to only those doctors. I was not saying that 100% Tablighi doctors take it. Hope that will make you sheath the Buhtan weapon for the time being. Come to bangalore.. visit Dr Shakeel sahab , Radiologist and Tableeghi elder from bangalore.. he runs ' Scan line '.. one of the best diagnostic centers.. he has placed a board inside which says boldly ' WE GIVE QUALITY AND NO CUTS '... and he sticks to that.. This is known as crowing. Anyways, Dr Shakil is a Consultant. And Consultants in this racket are actually victims along with the patients. There are many Consultants in B'bay also who don't GIVE cuts. My real issue is with taking cuts. The Shifa Superspeciality hospital at Bangalore, managed by the tableeghi doctors DO NOT take or give cuts.. and there are many Tableeghi doctors i know personally who DO NOT take or give cuts.. There are approximately 550 doctors (GPs) in Kurla, Muslim and non-Muslim. Only one of them does not take cuts. He is a Deobandi but not a Tablighi. May Allah give baraka in ur practice.. Aameen.