Thread
:
About praying behind an Imam following another madhhab
View Single Post
09-27-2009, 01:19 AM
#
1
Chooriwrocaxz
Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
559
Senior Member
About praying behind an Imam following another madhhab
I remember having read a post long time ago - from Mufti Husain if I remember correctly - stating that if the Imam makes something which is valid in his own
madhhab
, but that for the
madhhab
of the follower breaks the prayer (or break's one
wudu'
), the
Salah
of the follower wouldn't be valid.
So, if a Shafi'i
imam
bleeds before leading
Salah
, and doesn't take a new
wudu'
(since for Shafi'is bleeding doesn't break
wudu'
), the
Salah
of a Hanafi follower wouldn't be valid.
Or if a Hanbali makes
masah
on thin socks who are not adapt according to Hanafi standards, again the
Salah
of a Hanafi follower wouldn't be valid.
But I have read accounts of great Hanafi
Ulama'
(possibly even Imam Muhammad (ra) or Imam Abu Yusuf (ra)!) praying behind
imam
s of other
madhahib
who did something who invalidated their prayers according to the Hanafi
madhhab
but not according to the Imam's
madhhab
, and still considering their prayer completely fine and valid..
Also, some days ago I've read an account of Sahaba
praying behind each other even in presence of
ikhtilaf
about
tahara
issue (again about bleeding), but still considering their prayer valid..
I'd like to have some clarification,
Quote
Chooriwrocaxz
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Chooriwrocaxz
All times are GMT +1. The time now is
06:40 PM
.