DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - please advice: considering switching madhab from hanafi to hanbali

**Amomiamup** · 05-17-2011, 08:38 PM

It could probably be asked, "Why Hanbali?" With all due respect to the Madhab, why would you want to choose the Madhab which has always historically been the smallest, and has yet whose scholars have probably led to the most strife within the Ummah in relative terms (I don't mean to slight the Madhab, but rather call to attention the fact that the recent interest in it must have a cause that didn't exist in the Modern day)?

Kindly stop acting as an expert on Hanbali Madhab when you don't follow it yourself. Also kindly stay away from passing rulings over other madhabs or making comparisons between the madhabs.These issues don't fall in your jurisprudence.

05-17-2011, 08:38 PM	#9
Amomiamup Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 414 Senior Member	It could probably be asked, "Why Hanbali?" With all due respect to the Madhab, why would you want to choose the Madhab which has always historically been the smallest, and has yet whose scholars have probably led to the most strife within the Ummah in relative terms (I don't mean to slight the Madhab, but rather call to attention the fact that the recent interest in it must have a cause that didn't exist in the Modern day)? Kindly stop acting as an expert on Hanbali Madhab when you don't follow it yourself. Also kindly stay away from passing rulings over other madhabs or making comparisons between the madhabs.These issues don't fall in your jurisprudence.
	Quote