DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Friday Prayer sin - question ("he who misses three Friday prayers is kafir")

**Spongebob** · 05-20-2011, 01:25 AM

Ace Abbas is, apparently, a shafi'i, and they do not have the concept of karahah tahrimiyyah . . . In the shafi'i madh-hab, praying behind ahl al-bid'ah is permissible. In the hanafi madh-hab, praying behind ahl al-bid'ah is either [1] makruh tanzihan (al-haskafi and others) [2] makruh tahriman (ibn 'abidin mentions both opinions) which means one incurs sin if one performs it (i.e. it is akin to haram, except the strength of evidence is slightly weaker).

HOWEVER, none of the above is relevant if we are discussing a rafidi 'ja'fari'; they make takfir of as-sayyidah A'ishah radhiy Allah 'anha amongst other things which take them out of the fold of Islam, as far as I know.

was-salam

05-20-2011, 01:25 AM	#27
Spongebob Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 398 Senior Member	Ace Abbas is, apparently, a shafi'i, and they do not have the concept of karahah tahrimiyyah . . . In the shafi'i madh-hab, praying behind ahl al-bid'ah is permissible. In the hanafi madh-hab, praying behind ahl al-bid'ah is either [1] makruh tanzihan (al-haskafi and others) [2] makruh tahriman (ibn 'abidin mentions both opinions) which means one incurs sin if one performs it (i.e. it is akin to haram, except the strength of evidence is slightly weaker). HOWEVER, none of the above is relevant if we are discussing a rafidi 'ja'fari'; they make takfir of as-sayyidah A'ishah radhiy Allah 'anha amongst other things which take them out of the fold of Islam, as far as I know. was-salam
	Quote