DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Palestinian factions denounce murder of Italian activist by Salafi-extremists

**YmolafBp** · 04-17-2011, 01:07 PM

They're imprisoned Justly, Hamas declared a truce or a temporary cease-fire with Israel after the battles, but these guys they don't understand what a Truce means and why it is important in order for the people to regain their health and for the supplies to flow back in and in order for Hamas to regain their strength and formulate new strategies.

Hamas who are the legitimate government who was elected by the Muslims chose to have a truce, these guys will disobey and fire random rockets only to have Israel retaliate and destroy the entire Gaza strip, tighten the siege and block all paths. What Hamas does is that they don't kill them, they just arrest them and keep them in prison so that Israel wouldn't have an excuse and say "Hamas broke the truce thus they deserve to be bombarded" (Like in 2009 when Israel broke the truce). These extremists however cannot be arrested easily they will actually fire at the Hamas people and try to kill them so they have casualties usually when trying to stop these extremist groups... The extremists go even further by claiming that gaza is an emirate and that they choose the Ameer and that Hamas has to drop their weapons and follow the Ameer the Salafi extremists elected...it gets complicated.

Assalamu aliakum,

I wasn't supporting the Salafis - in fact I was doing the opposite. Let me re-write/re-phrase what I wrote.

Let's say they [the Salafis] were imprisoned unjustly. Is this the way to act [by killing an innocent person, who on top was supporting the Palestinian cause]? If they [the Salafis] are acting like this [i.e. irrationally, by killing an innocent person and Palestinian sympathizer] no matter what the reason for imprisonment, then I feel it was right for them to have been imprisoned [because people who are acting so irrationally probably also got jailed for something equally irrational and stupid].

04-17-2011, 01:07 PM	#37
YmolafBp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 425 Senior Member	They're imprisoned Justly, Hamas declared a truce or a temporary cease-fire with Israel after the battles, but these guys they don't understand what a Truce means and why it is important in order for the people to regain their health and for the supplies to flow back in and in order for Hamas to regain their strength and formulate new strategies. Hamas who are the legitimate government who was elected by the Muslims chose to have a truce, these guys will disobey and fire random rockets only to have Israel retaliate and destroy the entire Gaza strip, tighten the siege and block all paths. What Hamas does is that they don't kill them, they just arrest them and keep them in prison so that Israel wouldn't have an excuse and say "Hamas broke the truce thus they deserve to be bombarded" (Like in 2009 when Israel broke the truce). These extremists however cannot be arrested easily they will actually fire at the Hamas people and try to kill them so they have casualties usually when trying to stop these extremist groups... The extremists go even further by claiming that gaza is an emirate and that they choose the Ameer and that Hamas has to drop their weapons and follow the Ameer the Salafi extremists elected...it gets complicated. Assalamu aliakum, I wasn't supporting the Salafis - in fact I was doing the opposite. Let me re-write/re-phrase what I wrote. Let's say they [the Salafis] were imprisoned unjustly. Is this the way to act [by killing an innocent person, who on top was supporting the Palestinian cause]? If they [the Salafis] are acting like this [i.e. irrationally, by killing an innocent person and Palestinian sympathizer] no matter what the reason for imprisonment, then I feel it was right for them to have been imprisoned [because people who are acting so irrationally probably also got jailed for something equally irrational and stupid].
	Quote