DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - ATTENTION: PDF scan of the very rare, very sought after book of Shah Nimatullah (ra)

**chinesemedicine** · 05-18-2011, 07:25 AM

i am comparing the following 2 versions......

version 1.... http://www.scribd.com/doc/15012325/Q...llah-Shah-Wali
version 2.... http://spiritual-pakistan-future.blo...i%20%28R.A.%29 (found mid page.)

version 2 has omited a whole verse out. the omitted verse reads, "oos kay bad isfahan shehr say dajjal kafir zahir hoga. Isa (as) oos kay qatal karnay kay liyay asman say tashreef lay ayayngay".
translation: after that, from isfahan city, the kafir dajjal will appear. Isa (as) in order to slay him will come from the heavens.
(my urdu is on the point of non-existance so please correct me if i have made a mistake.)

the omitted verse appears in version 1 as the second to last verse. in version 2 it does not exist. i have not compared the versions enough to comment on any other discrepencies as yet.

my motive for comparing different versions is because i suspect some groups may be manipulating the sayings of Shah Nimatullah in order to lead unsuspecting muslims astray and to further their own cause.

.....and for those who understand the significance of this, the name akram and verses related to akram are not to be found in the first version which to me seems like the more comprehensive version of the 2.

05-18-2011, 07:25 AM	#17
chinesemedicine Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 506 Senior Member	i am comparing the following 2 versions...... version 1.... http://www.scribd.com/doc/15012325/Q...llah-Shah-Wali version 2.... http://spiritual-pakistan-future.blo...i%20%28R.A.%29 (found mid page.) version 2 has omited a whole verse out. the omitted verse reads, "oos kay bad isfahan shehr say dajjal kafir zahir hoga. Isa (as) oos kay qatal karnay kay liyay asman say tashreef lay ayayngay". translation: after that, from isfahan city, the kafir dajjal will appear. Isa (as) in order to slay him will come from the heavens. (my urdu is on the point of non-existance so please correct me if i have made a mistake.) the omitted verse appears in version 1 as the second to last verse. in version 2 it does not exist. i have not compared the versions enough to comment on any other discrepencies as yet. my motive for comparing different versions is because i suspect some groups may be manipulating the sayings of Shah Nimatullah in order to lead unsuspecting muslims astray and to further their own cause. .....and for those who understand the significance of this, the name akram and verses related to akram are not to be found in the first version which to me seems like the more comprehensive version of the 2.
	Quote