DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is Standing and reading Salaam accepted??

**ugosanchezo** · 05-02-2011, 01:22 PM

Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam states in a Hadith that if you dream of me, U Surely have as shaytaan cannot take my form.

In another hadith its stated that the worst lie is to say u have dreamt something when u didn't.

My bro did his alim course at a deobandi, wahaabi Darul Uloom in Newcastle, South Africa.

During one of his classes, his najdi teacher blurted out.
"All those that stand and read salaam wasted their time as their salaam is NOT ACCEPTED by Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam"

This made my bro very disheartened. He made dua to Allah Subhanahu wa Ta'ala as follows,
" O Allah, all these years I've been standing and sending salaam to Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam, is this all in vain."

Alhamdulillah, that very night he dreamt of Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam.
Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam tells him,
" O Abdur Rahman, whether you STAND OR SIT, I ( Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam) REPLY TO YOUR SALAAM."

The next day he related his dream to his Ustaad ( Rahmatulah Alai).
I can't remember this ustaads (Rahmatulah Alai) name but he is late. This ustaad founded Darul Uloom Newcastle.

His ustaad replied, Abdur Rahman, u must stand on the mimbar and inform the people ( wahaabis,etc) of ur dream, instruction."

I may well ask u , after reading this post, who Do YoU TRUST, HUZOOR e PAAK SALALAHU ALAI wa SALAM or the corrupt deobandi alims.???????????????????????????????????????????? ????????????

I have read the two posts in the Mawlid thread where you posts and were removed. Most of what you write is either emotion or a copy paste. In the above post I believe you are talking about Maulana Qasim Sema rehmatullah alayhi?

In anycase, while in one instance the teacher were najdi, wahabi, corrupt ulamas, later they become Ustaad rehmatullah alayh. So it is a bit confusing what you are posting.

Nonetheless, with regards to durood and salam, I recite durood standing, sitting, driving and even laying down. So I feel, if the quotation to Ml. Sema is correct he is referring to Salami/Qiyam etc after Jummah or in Mawlid. If that is the case, then his view is correct. As for the dream, then if that is correctly transmitted as well, it will also be correct that your brothers duroods have been accepted. It will not make any daleel for the practice. Sometime we accept the wrongs of our children too. Acceptance of that individual action will not mean that it is accepted mutlaqan.

Finally about Mawlid issues, I am happy that your brother is farigh from Newcastle, which means he has good command on arabic. Please ask him to accompany you on this forum. So we can have an "academic" discussion and not one governed by emotions. I will make sure your thread in that discussion will not be deleted, unless the emotions run too high, or instead of discussion either party simply starts copy pasting. If you agree, then please drop a message in the Sensitive QA section and I will make arrangements.

P.S I am not the mod who deleted your posts.

05-02-2011, 01:22 PM	#9
ugosanchezo Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 394 Senior Member	Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam states in a Hadith that if you dream of me, U Surely have as shaytaan cannot take my form. In another hadith its stated that the worst lie is to say u have dreamt something when u didn't. My bro did his alim course at a deobandi, wahaabi Darul Uloom in Newcastle, South Africa. During one of his classes, his najdi teacher blurted out. "All those that stand and read salaam wasted their time as their salaam is NOT ACCEPTED by Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam" This made my bro very disheartened. He made dua to Allah Subhanahu wa Ta'ala as follows, " O Allah, all these years I've been standing and sending salaam to Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam, is this all in vain." Alhamdulillah, that very night he dreamt of Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam. Huzoor e Paak Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam tells him, " O Abdur Rahman, whether you STAND OR SIT, I ( Salalahu Alaihi wa Salam) REPLY TO YOUR SALAAM." The next day he related his dream to his Ustaad ( Rahmatulah Alai). I can't remember this ustaads (Rahmatulah Alai) name but he is late. This ustaad founded Darul Uloom Newcastle. His ustaad replied, Abdur Rahman, u must stand on the mimbar and inform the people ( wahaabis,etc) of ur dream, instruction." I may well ask u , after reading this post, who Do YoU TRUST, HUZOOR e PAAK SALALAHU ALAI wa SALAM or the corrupt deobandi alims.???????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????? I have read the two posts in the Mawlid thread where you posts and were removed. Most of what you write is either emotion or a copy paste. In the above post I believe you are talking about Maulana Qasim Sema rehmatullah alayhi? In anycase, while in one instance the teacher were najdi, wahabi, corrupt ulamas, later they become Ustaad rehmatullah alayh. So it is a bit confusing what you are posting. Nonetheless, with regards to durood and salam, I recite durood standing, sitting, driving and even laying down. So I feel, if the quotation to Ml. Sema is correct he is referring to Salami/Qiyam etc after Jummah or in Mawlid. If that is the case, then his view is correct. As for the dream, then if that is correctly transmitted as well, it will also be correct that your brothers duroods have been accepted. It will not make any daleel for the practice. Sometime we accept the wrongs of our children too. Acceptance of that individual action will not mean that it is accepted mutlaqan. Finally about Mawlid issues, I am happy that your brother is farigh from Newcastle, which means he has good command on arabic. Please ask him to accompany you on this forum. So we can have an "academic" discussion and not one governed by emotions. I will make sure your thread in that discussion will not be deleted, unless the emotions run too high, or instead of discussion either party simply starts copy pasting. If you agree, then please drop a message in the Sensitive QA section and I will make arrangements. P.S I am not the mod who deleted your posts.
	Quote