DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**dgdhgjjgj** · 04-21-2011, 05:57 PM

Assalaamoalaykum-w-w
Jk for the responses. I am talking about total eradication of Urdu. I would have thought, instead of sentimental responses, someone would have talked about how whole societies have been affected. Someone said learn both languages or many. I am talking about children in Madresa who dont have time.
Seriuosly though, If given the choice of only one language, what would people want their children to learn..... I am for Arabic totally....

But still, why limit the choice? I mean we are learning english as well. While every Alim knows basic english he is still targeted the pulp out of him because he cannot speak eloquently as a khateeb. We have those threads on SF too.

So if the Alim can learn Arabic, as well as urdu sufficient enough to utilize urdu materials to increase in his knowledge, then that is more than sufficient. Add farsi to it, nurun ala nur.

Arabic is a must for alim anyway, so there is no question about it.

Along with this, if he can learn the local languages of his area, i.e different dialects etc. that is an aid for his da'wah work.

04-21-2011, 05:57 PM	#20
dgdhgjjgj Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 481 Senior Member	Assalaamoalaykum-w-w Jk for the responses. I am talking about total eradication of Urdu. I would have thought, instead of sentimental responses, someone would have talked about how whole societies have been affected. Someone said learn both languages or many. I am talking about children in Madresa who dont have time. Seriuosly though, If given the choice of only one language, what would people want their children to learn..... I am for Arabic totally.... But still, why limit the choice? I mean we are learning english as well. While every Alim knows basic english he is still targeted the pulp out of him because he cannot speak eloquently as a khateeb. We have those threads on SF too. So if the Alim can learn Arabic, as well as urdu sufficient enough to utilize urdu materials to increase in his knowledge, then that is more than sufficient. Add farsi to it, nurun ala nur. Arabic is a must for alim anyway, so there is no question about it. Along with this, if he can learn the local languages of his area, i.e different dialects etc. that is an aid for his da'wah work.
	Quote