DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Imam Malik's(rah) harsh words towards Imam Abu Hanifa(rah)

**oxinsnepe** · 04-17-2011, 09:29 AM

Salam Aleykum,

You're right, it's the people who stand out the most that get piked on usually...still what boggles my mind is "Why?" Does it have anything to do with Jahmiyyah and the creation of the Quran?

I downloaded the book, seems to be about the Jarh and Ta'adeel of the Rijal, should be an interesting read... or I'll just skip to Abu Hanifa's Chapter.

If you read from p. 187 onwards "رد الجرح الصادر من تعصب أو عداوة أو منافرة" you will get general guidelines on how to deal with these types of statements. I did a translation here, but you would be better off reading the original, of course.

Afterward, you can check out the parts of the book that deal specifically with Abu Hanifah

if you wish.

04-17-2011, 09:29 AM	#4
oxinsnepe Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 489 Senior Member	Salam Aleykum, You're right, it's the people who stand out the most that get piked on usually...still what boggles my mind is "Why?" Does it have anything to do with Jahmiyyah and the creation of the Quran? I downloaded the book, seems to be about the Jarh and Ta'adeel of the Rijal, should be an interesting read... or I'll just skip to Abu Hanifa's Chapter. If you read from p. 187 onwards "رد الجرح الصادر من تعصب أو عداوة أو منافرة" you will get general guidelines on how to deal with these types of statements. I did a translation here, but you would be better off reading the original, of course. Afterward, you can check out the parts of the book that deal specifically with Abu Hanifah if you wish.
	Quote