DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Why is there an anti-jihadi culture in tabligh jamaat?

**dafodilkemmy** · 04-11-2011, 08:11 PM

According to my observations there exists an anti-jihad culture in the whole of the Ummah, and not only Tabligh Jama'ah. So, you'll find them in TJ just as anywhere else. I think many Muslims have a warped understanding of what Jihad means due to (1) propaganda of Kuffar and (2) mischief done in the name of Jihad. They think Jihad simply means "slaughtering Kuffar", "kidnapping innocents" and "showing no mercy", but if you allude them to the jihadi stories compiled by Shaykh al-Hadith Mawlana Zakariyya in Hikaayatus Sahabah or Hadhrat-ji Mawlana Yusuf's explicit use of the word "Jihad" in chapters for Hayatus Sahabah they'll claim that this is something totally different.

These are just my general observations as I don't know which comments they actually made and how they replied to your advice. But at the same time I've witnessed myself Tablighi (elders) going to great lengths in defending Mujahideen. But the usual bickering and quarreling between both camps makes the gap just larger.

but what about the purana sathis who have spent many years and many 4 months learning the deen but then even after all this they still have an anti-jihad stance? surely they should know better after spending so much time and sacrifices in the service of the deen

also can you please please tell me who the tablighi elders are who defended the mujahideen and if possible the source for this .

i welcome comments from colonel hardstone, abu tamim, enigma and others.

04-11-2011, 08:11 PM	#4
dafodilkemmy Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 471 Senior Member	According to my observations there exists an anti-jihad culture in the whole of the Ummah, and not only Tabligh Jama'ah. So, you'll find them in TJ just as anywhere else. I think many Muslims have a warped understanding of what Jihad means due to (1) propaganda of Kuffar and (2) mischief done in the name of Jihad. They think Jihad simply means "slaughtering Kuffar", "kidnapping innocents" and "showing no mercy", but if you allude them to the jihadi stories compiled by Shaykh al-Hadith Mawlana Zakariyya in Hikaayatus Sahabah or Hadhrat-ji Mawlana Yusuf's explicit use of the word "Jihad" in chapters for Hayatus Sahabah they'll claim that this is something totally different. These are just my general observations as I don't know which comments they actually made and how they replied to your advice. But at the same time I've witnessed myself Tablighi (elders) going to great lengths in defending Mujahideen. But the usual bickering and quarreling between both camps makes the gap just larger. but what about the purana sathis who have spent many years and many 4 months learning the deen but then even after all this they still have an anti-jihad stance? surely they should know better after spending so much time and sacrifices in the service of the deen also can you please please tell me who the tablighi elders are who defended the mujahideen and if possible the source for this . i welcome comments from colonel hardstone, abu tamim, enigma and others.
	Quote