[Edqpdnuu]

here are my questions again (taken from my OP).......

1) why there is this type of culture (anti-jihadi) amongst some tablighi sathis?

2) where does this come from? (as this culture is not found in isolated cases).

3) do they have some sort of justification or some reason for this? (ie where does it stem from?)

4) are they wrong in this or are they right in this?

5) do you think that i am wrong in thinking that they have this anti-jihad culture? 1. The actual culture is don't discuss jihad in TJ.

2. When forced to speak on jihaad by some people who come with intention of provoking (my personal experience), yes we have to pro or anti stance. Then on a TJ forum from neutral instance it changes to anti-jihaadi.

3. reply no.2

4. as I said earlier to understand this read my earlier post.
to understand tableegh jamaat, one must posses the knowledge of the following:

The status of ummah globally, from villages of pakistan and India to cities of US and UK. And this is not through media or blogs.

An universal solution from washington to fiji, kazakhistan to melbourne, to this wide spectrum. You cannot have one for a village and another for a sophiscated city.

TJ in kashmir or chechanya is no different from Toronto.

Let me share my experience. We are a group of friends, I am alone from TJ. my friends use to argue the way it is done here in this forum and in this thread. My reply was silence. Later they formed a small organisation, they invited a scholar and had a small gathering. Many troubles started here. The list of troubles is a big one.

The statement made by them was "how do you manage TJ". 5. reply to 4.