DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**qQVXpYM6** · 03-17-2011, 01:25 PM

Assalaamu alaykum, so i am discussing some things with a ahle hadeeth guy. He cliams tariqahs are bidah and nothing good comes from them.

So i showed some quotes about ibn taymiyyah , the ones where he talks about abdal qadirs tariqah being the greatest, but the guy says that doesnt show how ibn taymiyya followed a tariqah. Also told him about ibn taymiyyahs commentary in majmu fatawa vol 10 1st edition riyadh.

Is there anymore evidences that ibn taymiyya is a qadiri ?
Are tariqahs bidah ?

Jzk,wsalaam

Ibn Taymiyya is a qadiri?? I have never heard that and if this is true I am going to do a halaal dance. I thought Ibn Taymiyya was staunch against tasawwuf but his student turned around and wrote a big book on tasawwuf? Maybe I misunderstood, I do have a weak understanding of things.

Reading this thread I have come to realize we have some big time Ulama on this thread, on sunniforum, jayyid Ulama who can pinpoint the most subtle points in deen - you mean all of these big scholars from all over the world never thought tariq to be biddat, all of these big buzrughs passed practicing preaching and furthering their tariqs,these are people who willingly gave up several halaal things just to abstain from one haraam thing but no they never found this subtle point that what they were practicing was biddat, yet here we have these intelligent people who are finding the truth behind these tariqs that they are all innovations..wah. Sunniforum is truly an amazing place. I know sunniforum doesnt advocate this jahalath.

03-17-2011, 01:25 PM	#21
qQVXpYM6 Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 413 Senior Member	Assalaamu alaykum, so i am discussing some things with a ahle hadeeth guy. He cliams tariqahs are bidah and nothing good comes from them. So i showed some quotes about ibn taymiyyah , the ones where he talks about abdal qadirs tariqah being the greatest, but the guy says that doesnt show how ibn taymiyya followed a tariqah. Also told him about ibn taymiyyahs commentary in majmu fatawa vol 10 1st edition riyadh. Is there anymore evidences that ibn taymiyya is a qadiri ? Are tariqahs bidah ? Jzk,wsalaam Ibn Taymiyya is a qadiri?? I have never heard that and if this is true I am going to do a halaal dance. I thought Ibn Taymiyya was staunch against tasawwuf but his student turned around and wrote a big book on tasawwuf? Maybe I misunderstood, I do have a weak understanding of things. Reading this thread I have come to realize we have some big time Ulama on this thread, on sunniforum, jayyid Ulama who can pinpoint the most subtle points in deen - you mean all of these big scholars from all over the world never thought tariq to be biddat, all of these big buzrughs passed practicing preaching and furthering their tariqs,these are people who willingly gave up several halaal things just to abstain from one haraam thing but no they never found this subtle point that what they were practicing was biddat, yet here we have these intelligent people who are finding the truth behind these tariqs that they are all innovations..wah. Sunniforum is truly an amazing place. I know sunniforum doesnt advocate this jahalath.
	Quote