DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**exschke** · 03-18-2011, 01:00 PM

The burden of proof for no good reason has been dropped at my shoulders ( circular arguments).However, I would like to ask a few basic questions and would see if any evidence can be given for that.
1.The Naqashbandi Tareeqah supposedly originated from Abu Bakr Al-Sadeeq ra. Kindly, tell me how many "mureeds" did he have? How many Wazaif did he give and how many times he used this word "Naqashbandeya"?

The Hanbali Madhab supposedly originated from Imam Ahmad :rahmaL. How many times did he use the word "Hanbaliyia?"

Conclusion: dr ati is a Mubtadi` for ascribing himself to the group called Hanbali.

3.Why almost all of these tariqas were started by the Persian and the arabs remained deprived of this"" barakaa"?

Why almost off of these Hadith compilations were written by the Persian and the arabs remained deprived of this "" barakaa"?

Conclusion: Hadith compilations are bida`, and must not be trusted.

Of course, I don't believe either of these statements, just applying dr ati's logic to other scenarios.

03-18-2011, 01:00 PM	#30
exschke Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 546 Senior Member	The burden of proof for no good reason has been dropped at my shoulders ( circular arguments).However, I would like to ask a few basic questions and would see if any evidence can be given for that. 1.The Naqashbandi Tareeqah supposedly originated from Abu Bakr Al-Sadeeq ra. Kindly, tell me how many "mureeds" did he have? How many Wazaif did he give and how many times he used this word "Naqashbandeya"? The Hanbali Madhab supposedly originated from Imam Ahmad :rahmaL. How many times did he use the word "Hanbaliyia?" Conclusion: dr ati is a Mubtadi` for ascribing himself to the group called Hanbali. 3.Why almost all of these tariqas were started by the Persian and the arabs remained deprived of this"" barakaa"? Why almost off of these Hadith compilations were written by the Persian and the arabs remained deprived of this "" barakaa"? Conclusion: Hadith compilations are bida`, and must not be trusted. Of course, I don't believe either of these statements, just applying dr ati's logic to other scenarios.
	Quote