DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Ikhtilaf -- a treatise by Muhadith Hijaz Muhammad Hayat Sindi (d. 1163 AH)

**Lerpenoaneway** · 03-20-2011, 05:54 AM

@ suleimanibnsalim

I had written a long post but the browser crashed. anyway, the point is that we have to unbiased and examine arguments from both sides. I think you understand the Ashari creed better than me so, I would be asking you to explain me.

What does Imam al-Haramain Abul Ma`ali Juwayni mean about TWO HANDS TWO EYES FACE in his book al-Irshad ??

suleimanibnsalim I want you to explain to me the position of Imam Haramayn on Two Hands, Two Eyes and Face......
what does it mean ?

Did Imam al Haramayn not repudiate his positions in Kitab al Irshad and his final stance is what is in his Risala al Nizamiyya. Besides that, where does he say that he personally believed that Allah has "Two eyes"? Same with Izz ibn Abdas Salam and al-Baqillani.. Explain where they personally affirmed it.

You seem to believe that Allah has aynayan, so please provide just one Sahih hadith that prooves this rather than quotes ascribed to men who can make mistakes in creed unlike Anbiyya.

03-20-2011, 05:54 AM	#20
Lerpenoaneway Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 442 Senior Member	@ suleimanibnsalim I had written a long post but the browser crashed. anyway, the point is that we have to unbiased and examine arguments from both sides. I think you understand the Ashari creed better than me so, I would be asking you to explain me. What does Imam al-Haramain Abul Ma`ali Juwayni mean about TWO HANDS TWO EYES FACE in his book al-Irshad ?? suleimanibnsalim I want you to explain to me the position of Imam Haramayn on Two Hands, Two Eyes and Face...... what does it mean ? Did Imam al Haramayn not repudiate his positions in Kitab al Irshad and his final stance is what is in his Risala al Nizamiyya. Besides that, where does he say that he personally believed that Allah has "Two eyes"? Same with Izz ibn Abdas Salam and al-Baqillani.. Explain where they personally affirmed it. You seem to believe that Allah has aynayan, so please provide just one Sahih hadith that prooves this rather than quotes ascribed to men who can make mistakes in creed unlike Anbiyya.
	Quote