DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Evoncalabbalo** · 04-04-2011, 09:40 PM

P.S: Now, his Fatwaas and views on Tassawuff make sense as he is close follower of Sunnah and doesn't like any deviation from it.

Sorry bruv,but I have to flag this comment up. Are you implying that any person who disagrees with him is somehow not on the sunnah or less on the sunnah?

Im sorry bruv,the word sunnah is being too simplified and alot of the times, the different meanings the word 'sunnah' has in the different fields of Ilm gets interchanged without explaining how sometimes in different fields on ilm, the word 'sunnah' can and does mean different things.

Mufti A.S Desai sahib may well have very very different views to other scholars of other schools, so are you implying that those scholars of other schools are somehow not as close on the sunnah as Mufti Sahib?

Islam is not and has not been one size fits all.

No debate or argument intended CH.

04-04-2011, 09:40 PM	#8
Evoncalabbalo Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 572 Senior Member	P.S: Now, his Fatwaas and views on Tassawuff make sense as he is close follower of Sunnah and doesn't like any deviation from it. Sorry bruv,but I have to flag this comment up. Are you implying that any person who disagrees with him is somehow not on the sunnah or less on the sunnah? Im sorry bruv,the word sunnah is being too simplified and alot of the times, the different meanings the word 'sunnah' has in the different fields of Ilm gets interchanged without explaining how sometimes in different fields on ilm, the word 'sunnah' can and does mean different things. Mufti A.S Desai sahib may well have very very different views to other scholars of other schools, so are you implying that those scholars of other schools are somehow not as close on the sunnah as Mufti Sahib? Islam is not and has not been one size fits all. No debate or argument intended CH.
	Quote