DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Abaanto** · 10-17-2010, 02:46 AM

Brother TripolySunni,

Why you do not give me , you the proof in the Quran that dead can hear us ?

-1) the body is turning to dust ok ?

2) the Soul is in the barzak

3) there is like a border betwwen the dead people and the alives

4) If ou say that the dead can hear then they are alive ?

5) If they can hear us they are like Allah SWT rhey hear everything ?

I ask Allah SWT to guide us and to forgive us, Ameen.

I say there are several opinions, Some say they hear, some say They hear but it does not benefit them so it's like they never heard, some say they don't hear at all... only at the beginning they hear the footsteps of those who are burying them and then they are faced with the angels and are asked in the grave about what they did (This is the torture part) and then they never hear anymore.

I've personally not taken an opinion yet as I never researched this myself, But I was asking you what your proof is for them Not hearing... just out of curiosity.

10-17-2010, 02:46 AM	#36
Abaanto Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 512 Senior Member	Brother TripolySunni, Why you do not give me , you the proof in the Quran that dead can hear us ? -1) the body is turning to dust ok ? 2) the Soul is in the barzak 3) there is like a border betwwen the dead people and the alives 4) If ou say that the dead can hear then they are alive ? 5) If they can hear us they are like Allah SWT rhey hear everything ? I ask Allah SWT to guide us and to forgive us, Ameen. I say there are several opinions, Some say they hear, some say They hear but it does not benefit them so it's like they never heard, some say they don't hear at all... only at the beginning they hear the footsteps of those who are burying them and then they are faced with the angels and are asked in the grave about what they did (This is the torture part) and then they never hear anymore. I've personally not taken an opinion yet as I never researched this myself, But I was asking you what your proof is for them Not hearing... just out of curiosity.
	Quote