DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Ashraf 'Ali Thanvi: Salaf took literal meaning of sifaat

**vipBrooriErok** · 11-23-2010, 12:15 AM

wa'alaikum assalam wrhmt wbrkt

huhu. not in the ranks salaf. khalaf especially deobandis.

sorry my mistake.. Not salaf or khalaf rather deobandies as pointed out from the your own quotation. The object of the thread you created was NOT to discuss akhi. Why cant you own up to that. It was to gloat about some finding you came across thinking it supports the salafi athari creed. while the whole risalah is establishing the salaf creed of making tafweed in both kunh as well as kayf. And at the same time establishing the athari creed as a part of khalaf (i.e ahl ta'weel) NOT salaf! Please wake up and smell the coffee. If you cannot understand that from the risalah then your understanding is deficient, and thats not my problem.

In anycase, I do not wish to discuss since I feel you are being unreasonable in your intent of this thread. Your purpose and your inciting comments like the one below expose your intent. Why should I entertain you in your endeavor?

These are your own wrong assumptions which you cannot prove that is why you are avoiding to even explain your objections. Read the risalah akhi it all explained there.

I can further help this much that I will scan those suplementary writeups and post them as well. So no one can say that deobandies are hiding something.

11-23-2010, 12:15 AM	#27
vipBrooriErok Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 381 Senior Member	wa'alaikum assalam wrhmt wbrkt huhu. not in the ranks salaf. khalaf especially deobandis. sorry my mistake.. Not salaf or khalaf rather deobandies as pointed out from the your own quotation. The object of the thread you created was NOT to discuss akhi. Why cant you own up to that. It was to gloat about some finding you came across thinking it supports the salafi athari creed. while the whole risalah is establishing the salaf creed of making tafweed in both kunh as well as kayf. And at the same time establishing the athari creed as a part of khalaf (i.e ahl ta'weel) NOT salaf! Please wake up and smell the coffee. If you cannot understand that from the risalah then your understanding is deficient, and thats not my problem. In anycase, I do not wish to discuss since I feel you are being unreasonable in your intent of this thread. Your purpose and your inciting comments like the one below expose your intent. Why should I entertain you in your endeavor? These are your own wrong assumptions which you cannot prove that is why you are avoiding to even explain your objections. Read the risalah akhi it all explained there. I can further help this much that I will scan those suplementary writeups and post them as well. So no one can say that deobandies are hiding something.
	Quote