DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - a list of deobandi scholars who are athari/salafi in aqida

**rarpAcconavox** · 03-24-2011, 04:13 PM

Salaam

I think the brother is referring to Tafweed of Kayf/Kayfiyyah instead of the normally understood Tafweed-ul-Ma`naa of which you are referring to.

I would be really surprised if the above listed scholars really held/hold the position of Tafweed of Kayfiyyah absolutely (instead of Tafweed-ul-Ma`naa, whilst negating Kayfiyyah) other than possibly just a difference of terms, if thats what the above scholars held anyway.

Wassalaam

I was being sarcastic, sorry if that wasn't obvious.

My point is that these scholars are most likely mufawwid (of al-Ma`na), and bringing one quote doesn't change anything, especially when the quotes could be understood to mean either tafwid of ma`na or kayfiyyah. If we are to assume that these scholars have the Salafi belief of tafwid of al-Kayfiyya based on these quotes, then they should be willing to assume that the likes of ibn Qudama, adh-Dhahabi

should be considered to be mufawwids of al-ma`na based on similar quotes from them indicating so.

03-24-2011, 04:13 PM	#9
rarpAcconavox Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 411 Senior Member	Salaam I think the brother is referring to Tafweed of Kayf/Kayfiyyah instead of the normally understood Tafweed-ul-Ma`naa of which you are referring to. I would be really surprised if the above listed scholars really held/hold the position of Tafweed of Kayfiyyah absolutely (instead of Tafweed-ul-Ma`naa, whilst negating Kayfiyyah) other than possibly just a difference of terms, if thats what the above scholars held anyway. Wassalaam I was being sarcastic, sorry if that wasn't obvious. My point is that these scholars are most likely mufawwid (of al-Ma`na), and bringing one quote doesn't change anything, especially when the quotes could be understood to mean either tafwid of ma`na or kayfiyyah. If we are to assume that these scholars have the Salafi belief of tafwid of al-Kayfiyya based on these quotes, then they should be willing to assume that the likes of ibn Qudama, adh-Dhahabi should be considered to be mufawwids of al-ma`na based on similar quotes from them indicating so.
	Quote