DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hanbali site says Imam Ahmad, Shafi and Malik agreed on folding hands on chest

**Vigeommighica** · 05-17-2010, 11:30 AM

An-Nawawi did not mention any other Ahadith in Al-Khulasah then the hadith of Wail bin Hujr (radiallahu anh). Ibn Hajar has mentioned it in his Bulugh al Maram.

Ibn Rajab al Hanbali in his Sharh of Bukhari Fath ul Bari hadith 740 said that putting the hands on the chest:
Was narrated as the action of Ali (radiallahu anh)
Was narrated as the action of Sa'eed bin Jubair (rah)
An opinion by Imam Shafi'i (rah)
An opinion by Imam Ahmad (rah)

Another thing a authentic hadeeth which described the way the Prophet (salallahu alayhi was sallam) used to put his hands over one another: He put his right hand on top of his left hand, wrist and forearm.

Isn't such position difficult to achieve with the hands under the navel ?

You are now clutching on to straws. Seriously you need to sit back and reflect.

I have clearly mentioned to you, show me where Imam Nawawi and Ibn Hajar have classed the Hadith as sahih. Please answer the question.

There is also one other important point supporting the case that the hadith of مؤمل is certainly ضعيف. I leave that point until you answer my question.

Another thing a authentic hadeeth which described the way the Prophet (salallahu alayhi was sallam) used to put his hands over one another: He put his right hand [U]on top of his left hand, wrist and forearm.

Isn't such position difficult to achieve with the hands under the navel ? This statement actually just made me smirk, honestly please provide better points.

As for the positions you mention, remind me about this point after you TRULY answer the points I have raised. It is time you answer questions properly.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best.

05-17-2010, 11:30 AM	#12
Vigeommighica Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 405 Senior Member	An-Nawawi did not mention any other Ahadith in Al-Khulasah then the hadith of Wail bin Hujr (radiallahu anh). Ibn Hajar has mentioned it in his Bulugh al Maram. Ibn Rajab al Hanbali in his Sharh of Bukhari Fath ul Bari hadith 740 said that putting the hands on the chest: Was narrated as the action of Ali (radiallahu anh) Was narrated as the action of Sa'eed bin Jubair (rah) An opinion by Imam Shafi'i (rah) An opinion by Imam Ahmad (rah) Another thing a authentic hadeeth which described the way the Prophet (salallahu alayhi was sallam) used to put his hands over one another: He put his right hand on top of his left hand, wrist and forearm. Isn't such position difficult to achieve with the hands under the navel ? You are now clutching on to straws. Seriously you need to sit back and reflect. I have clearly mentioned to you, show me where Imam Nawawi and Ibn Hajar have classed the Hadith as sahih. Please answer the question. There is also one other important point supporting the case that the hadith of مؤمل is certainly ضعيف. I leave that point until you answer my question. Another thing a authentic hadeeth which described the way the Prophet (salallahu alayhi was sallam) used to put his hands over one another: He put his right hand [U]on top of his left hand, wrist and forearm. Isn't such position difficult to achieve with the hands under the navel ? This statement actually just made me smirk, honestly please provide better points. As for the positions you mention, remind me about this point after you TRULY answer the points I have raised. It is time you answer questions properly. and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best.
	Quote