[steevytraunse]

I get the impression that Maulana is asking the critics to put forward their points in a matter of fact way - he is not taking either of the parties to task.

This is the sort of unity that might take us forward to some extent.

Brother Maripat;

Are you sure Maulana is not taking Mr Zakir Naik to task when he says the below ?

I know zakir naik personally, he is my friend since 20yrs, i told him not to do mufti's work, not to be a mujtahid, your work is not to give fatwa, you are not here to present new rulings. You(Zakir naik) must introduce islam to the whole world.