DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Mujaddid Alf-e-Thani's stance against Bid'ah Hasanah

**hotsaucemidl** · 01-30-2012, 09:31 PM

aoa,

really now. what about 20 rakat tarawih, the mushaf etc...pretty well-known good bidahs. and isnt there a hadith that describes the reward for someone who introduces a good practice in religion?you have to see whether something that is new is against shariah or not. you cant just brush them all away in similar fashion. the salafis always stumble when it comes to hadrat Umar (r.a).shows the fallacy of their arguments. but i am sure mujaddid alf-e-thani meant something else which i have not comprehended.Allahualam

...It also can be understood from the above explanation of bid'a that many things were not needed in the time of Allah's Messenger , but were established later to achieve a religious objective, cannot be included in the realm of bid'a (in the legal sense) either, [even though they may be considered bid'a in the literal sense, i.e., "an innovation" or "something new." Many times the later is intended when referencing a certain matter to be a good or bad bid'a, since every action legally considered a bid'a can only be reprehensible]. Post # 7

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...light=bid%27ah

01-30-2012, 09:31 PM	#5
hotsaucemidl Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 508 Senior Member	aoa, really now. what about 20 rakat tarawih, the mushaf etc...pretty well-known good bidahs. and isnt there a hadith that describes the reward for someone who introduces a good practice in religion?you have to see whether something that is new is against shariah or not. you cant just brush them all away in similar fashion. the salafis always stumble when it comes to hadrat Umar (r.a).shows the fallacy of their arguments. but i am sure mujaddid alf-e-thani meant something else which i have not comprehended.Allahualam ...It also can be understood from the above explanation of bid'a that many things were not needed in the time of Allah's Messenger , but were established later to achieve a religious objective, cannot be included in the realm of bid'a (in the legal sense) either, [even though they may be considered bid'a in the literal sense, i.e., "an innovation" or "something new." Many times the later is intended when referencing a certain matter to be a good or bad bid'a, since every action legally considered a bid'a can only be reprehensible]. Post # 7 http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...light=bid%27ah
	Quote