DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Mujaddid Alf-e-Thani's stance against Bid'ah Hasanah

**duceswild** · 02-09-2012, 12:05 AM

For example take the hadith: “The Religion is naseeha (sincerity and sincere advice).”*[Saheeh Muslim]

Ist case is a person who accepts good bidah. He would consider a innovation in naseeha as permissible and good when the goodness of the innovated naseeha has a basis in shariah

2nd case also accepts innovation in naseeha, the only difference bbeing that he does not consider it a "bidah" as the permissibility of innovation is part of shariah and not a new addition to it.

The 3rd category is were issues and difference really lie. As their definition of innovation would have to consider a innovation in naseeha to be forbidden as a naseeha cannot be done in any way or manner other than which the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him, did. The hadith considers naseeha as an aspect of religion hence a classification into secular and religious matter wouldn't apply to this.

02-09-2012, 12:05 AM	#14
duceswild Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 464 Senior Member	For example take the hadith: “The Religion is naseeha (sincerity and sincere advice).”*[Saheeh Muslim] Ist case is a person who accepts good bidah. He would consider a innovation in naseeha as permissible and good when the goodness of the innovated naseeha has a basis in shariah 2nd case also accepts innovation in naseeha, the only difference bbeing that he does not consider it a "bidah" as the permissibility of innovation is part of shariah and not a new addition to it. The 3rd category is were issues and difference really lie. As their definition of innovation would have to consider a innovation in naseeha to be forbidden as a naseeha cannot be done in any way or manner other than which the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him, did. The hadith considers naseeha as an aspect of religion hence a classification into secular and religious matter wouldn't apply to this.
	Quote