DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hamza Yusuf on the Lahori Ahmadis / Qadianis

**VanDerSmok** · 10-07-2012, 09:55 PM

Mufti Jumah holds the same opinion. Why dont you go have a debate with him ? And there are tons of ssalafis sitting in US and UK with the same opinion. Show some balance in your targetting.

No one has openly accepted their opinion, as it has no yet moved to a place that invites attention or criticism. Therefore you would see silence mostly unless a scholar has directly faced this issue.

Anyone who says this is wrong, be he Salafi, Sufi, or whatever he wants to present himself as. If we're not bound by the ijmaa' as-sahabah and the agreement of the Four Schools, then are we bound by anything at all?

What's more, how can you say that it hasn't moved to a place where it invites criticism? Anyone expressing a view like this in public is effectively leaving off the ijmaa of the Sahabah and the agreement of thousands of great scholars from all Four Schools. People who give speeches on the incumbency of 8 rak'ahs taraweeh are shot down like WW1 planes meeting Sidewinder missiles, so why is this going unchallenged?

10-07-2012, 09:55 PM	#25
VanDerSmok Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 521 Senior Member	Mufti Jumah holds the same opinion. Why dont you go have a debate with him ? And there are tons of ssalafis sitting in US and UK with the same opinion. Show some balance in your targetting. No one has openly accepted their opinion, as it has no yet moved to a place that invites attention or criticism. Therefore you would see silence mostly unless a scholar has directly faced this issue. Anyone who says this is wrong, be he Salafi, Sufi, or whatever he wants to present himself as. If we're not bound by the ijmaa' as-sahabah and the agreement of the Four Schools, then are we bound by anything at all? What's more, how can you say that it hasn't moved to a place where it invites criticism? Anyone expressing a view like this in public is effectively leaving off the ijmaa of the Sahabah and the agreement of thousands of great scholars from all Four Schools. People who give speeches on the incumbency of 8 rak'ahs taraweeh are shot down like WW1 planes meeting Sidewinder missiles, so why is this going unchallenged?
	Quote