[gactanync]

Being a comic book fan myself, I guess you first have to define what it means to be a "good comic book movie". Is it a movie that stays close to the source material or is it just a good movie that happens to be based on a comic book.

In terms of staying close to the source material and being good, I have to say either The Crow or Sin City. In terms of just kicking ass as a movie, I would have to say Batman Begins...hands...down.

Spider-man is my favourite comic, so it really does pain me to say that it does not make my "Best comic book movie of all time" list, although I did still enjoy both Spidey films.