DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is he who died realy dead?(if you read harry potter, dont read thistill you read HBP)

**DJElizardo** · 04-22-2006, 08:00 AM

I think Dumbledore is at least physically dead now. I don't believe he had a horcrux but if he did perhaps Fawkes is his horcrux. He says that it is not a very good idea to make an animal a horcrux but phoenixes are immortal, at the very least there is a stronger connection between them than master and pet.

Oh yeah and now we have 3+ years of speculating "WHO IS R.A.N.?" unless I am a prat and missed something very obvious in a previous book.

04-22-2006, 08:00 AM	#16
DJElizardo Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 456 Senior Member	I think Dumbledore is at least physically dead now. I don't believe he had a horcrux but if he did perhaps Fawkes is his horcrux. He says that it is not a very good idea to make an animal a horcrux but phoenixes are immortal, at the very least there is a stronger connection between them than master and pet. Oh yeah and now we have 3+ years of speculating "WHO IS R.A.N.?" unless I am a prat and missed something very obvious in a previous book.
	Quote