DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is he who died realy dead?(if you read harry potter, dont read thistill you read HBP)

**Vkowefek** · 10-17-2005, 08:00 AM

Another descrepancy, When snape performs "avada Kedavra", it describes the effects wrong. Every other time it has described the peoples deaths as instant in a flash of green light, not having lifted them of the ground and thrown them down. Why was dumbledores different?

Im also realy starting to beleive it was regulus. THat whole passage is just starting to click(the note)

BTW, I'm sorry if someone read this and got the book spoiled, but dont blame me or anyone else in this thread. I warned people in the title.....

As far as the Avada Kedavra, one death eater said in book 5 that you need to really mean the curse for it to happen (Lestrange?), obviously Snape didn't really mean it (I think Dumbledore begged him to kill him, not to have mercy) and Harry doesn't recover from his curse immediatly (as Dumbledore did not die from the curse) but until a few moments passed (Dumbledore hits the ground.
As for Regulus, that makes more sense now that I think about it. There was a Heavy gold locket that no one could open in the Black house i think and the fake horcrux is described as being smaller than the real one.

10-17-2005, 08:00 AM	#2
Vkowefek Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 389 Senior Member	Another descrepancy, When snape performs "avada Kedavra", it describes the effects wrong. Every other time it has described the peoples deaths as instant in a flash of green light, not having lifted them of the ground and thrown them down. Why was dumbledores different? Im also realy starting to beleive it was regulus. THat whole passage is just starting to click(the note) BTW, I'm sorry if someone read this and got the book spoiled, but dont blame me or anyone else in this thread. I warned people in the title..... As far as the Avada Kedavra, one death eater said in book 5 that you need to really mean the curse for it to happen (Lestrange?), obviously Snape didn't really mean it (I think Dumbledore begged him to kill him, not to have mercy) and Harry doesn't recover from his curse immediatly (as Dumbledore did not die from the curse) but until a few moments passed (Dumbledore hits the ground. As for Regulus, that makes more sense now that I think about it. There was a Heavy gold locket that no one could open in the Black house i think and the fake horcrux is described as being smaller than the real one.
	Quote