DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - GOP State Legislator Says Homosexuality Is More Dangerous Than Terrorism

**grudabor** · 09-12-2011, 07:50 PM

So Foster SAID that she said it but when he quoted her, that isn't exactly what she said.... Was she spouting nonesense? Sure. Is she a moron? Probably. I am not sure why you say that she was comparing apples and oranges...I know the common saying but isn't comparing apples and oranges a valid comparision? So basically you just posted to show that you agreed with what I posted? I am a bit surprised that you agree with me. I also agree with you that just posting what she said would probably have been enough to spark some responses. I am not sure why Yggdrasil has such an affinity for exaggeration. Esp in a case like this where what she ACTUALLY said was inflammatory enough...

The goal of the idea that you shouldn’t compare Apples to Oranges is that the two fruit are dissimilar in almost every way.

In discussing Terrorist Attacks, she specified a distinct number of attacks, and a reasonably rounded number of victims. Those are the Apples.

In discussing AIDS/HIV, she completely failed to state how many people have been diagnosed with AIDS/HIV – not even an approximate number - and yet gave a wildly generalized single number of victims who perished of the disease. Those are the Oranges.

If she had checked this site: http://www.healthline.com/adamcontent/aids, she could have stated the following:
“…AIDS is the fifth leading cause of death among people aged 25 - 44 in the United States, down from number one in 1995. About 25 million people worldwide have died from this infection since the start of the epidemic, and in 2006, there were approximately 40 million people around the world living with HIV/AIDS.…”

Something along these lines would have resulted in her comparing Apples to Apples, even though there still would have been some hyperbole in her statement.

09-12-2011, 07:50 PM	#7
grudabor Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 493 Senior Member	So Foster SAID that she said it but when he quoted her, that isn't exactly what she said.... Was she spouting nonesense? Sure. Is she a moron? Probably. I am not sure why you say that she was comparing apples and oranges...I know the common saying but isn't comparing apples and oranges a valid comparision? So basically you just posted to show that you agreed with what I posted? I am a bit surprised that you agree with me. I also agree with you that just posting what she said would probably have been enough to spark some responses. I am not sure why Yggdrasil has such an affinity for exaggeration. Esp in a case like this where what she ACTUALLY said was inflammatory enough... The goal of the idea that you shouldn’t compare Apples to Oranges is that the two fruit are dissimilar in almost every way. In discussing Terrorist Attacks, she specified a distinct number of attacks, and a reasonably rounded number of victims. Those are the Apples. In discussing AIDS/HIV, she completely failed to state how many people have been diagnosed with AIDS/HIV – not even an approximate number - and yet gave a wildly generalized single number of victims who perished of the disease. Those are the Oranges. If she had checked this site: http://www.healthline.com/adamcontent/aids, she could have stated the following: “…AIDS is the fifth leading cause of death among people aged 25 - 44 in the United States, down from number one in 1995. About 25 million people worldwide have died from this infection since the start of the epidemic, and in 2006, there were approximately 40 million people around the world living with HIV/AIDS.…” Something along these lines would have resulted in her comparing Apples to Apples, even though there still would have been some hyperbole in her statement.
	Quote