DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Deobandi Shaykh Husain Ahmad Madani on Stamp Paper !!

**zithromaxlinks** · 09-03-2012, 01:04 AM

[QUOTE=ahamed_sharif;813507]Assalamu alaykum

Let me quote what br Mohtashim has said;

When a dollar (or a rupee) note with human picture falls on the floor and you are in salah, the ruling given was that since the image is not recognisable in standing posture, the salah is valid.

Now your taqwa says:

What about when you go in sajdah? u r few inches from the note?

I give up and salute your taqwah.
QUOTE]

this ruling is about money which has images of faces on them over which we do not have any control.

this particular ruling does not give permission for making images with human faces on them, but clarifies the situation if money were to fall out from ones pockets when in the state of salaat.

this was the actual quote...

When a coin or paper currency falls from your pocket while you are praying salah, it does not invalidate your salah. Because, if you are standing and the currency is on the ground; with that distance the face is not very much visible.

the defining point in that ruling is with that distance the face is not very much visible it is of this reason that i asked him for clarification what the ruling is when the human image DOES become clearer when a person inevitably changes position in salaat.

09-03-2012, 01:04 AM	#32
zithromaxlinks Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 560 Senior Member	[QUOTE=ahamed_sharif;813507]Assalamu alaykum Let me quote what br Mohtashim has said; When a dollar (or a rupee) note with human picture falls on the floor and you are in salah, the ruling given was that since the image is not recognisable in standing posture, the salah is valid. Now your taqwa says: What about when you go in sajdah? u r few inches from the note? I give up and salute your taqwah. QUOTE] this ruling is about money which has images of faces on them over which we do not have any control. this particular ruling does not give permission for making images with human faces on them, but clarifies the situation if money were to fall out from ones pockets when in the state of salaat. this was the actual quote... When a coin or paper currency falls from your pocket while you are praying salah, it does not invalidate your salah. Because, if you are standing and the currency is on the ground; with that distance the face is not very much visible. the defining point in that ruling is with that distance the face is not very much visible it is of this reason that i asked him for clarification what the ruling is when the human image DOES become clearer when a person inevitably changes position in salaat.
	Quote