DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**bribiaLaubysdggf** · 09-03-2012, 06:16 AM

has any amil ever asked a jinn from the salaf as to which is the correct aqeedah and which path should we follow....madhabs or salafism?

I dont think we would get an appopriate or straightforward answer. Firstly I hear Jinn have short attention spans and dont like to think or speak too many complicated things. Secondly, their were no madhabs during the time of the salaf. Madhabs institutionalized around the 4th-5th century. Most of the salafs were in so close proximity to the time of nabi s.a.s that the oral transmission of hadith and teaching around that and Quran was sufficient. Jinn will probably say both are correct and that is the logical answer. Madhabs are correct because they are based on classical scholarship by great, transformed souls and salafism is also true since it conforms with the hadith of prophet that hold onto the Quran and sunnah and that is the motto of the salafis.

If prophets didnt resolve the disunity amongst humans and our prophet s.a.s clearly gave hadith to sectarianism, Khidr a.s wont be able to do that as well nor would any Jinns. Quran also points towards a sectarian nature of human beings.

09-03-2012, 06:16 AM	#25
bribiaLaubysdggf Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 536 Senior Member	has any amil ever asked a jinn from the salaf as to which is the correct aqeedah and which path should we follow....madhabs or salafism? I dont think we would get an appopriate or straightforward answer. Firstly I hear Jinn have short attention spans and dont like to think or speak too many complicated things. Secondly, their were no madhabs during the time of the salaf. Madhabs institutionalized around the 4th-5th century. Most of the salafs were in so close proximity to the time of nabi s.a.s that the oral transmission of hadith and teaching around that and Quran was sufficient. Jinn will probably say both are correct and that is the logical answer. Madhabs are correct because they are based on classical scholarship by great, transformed souls and salafism is also true since it conforms with the hadith of prophet that hold onto the Quran and sunnah and that is the motto of the salafis. If prophets didnt resolve the disunity amongst humans and our prophet s.a.s clearly gave hadith to sectarianism, Khidr a.s wont be able to do that as well nor would any Jinns. Quran also points towards a sectarian nature of human beings.
	Quote