I am still waiting for your answer. You have tried to stop a man from following the prophet's commands. So you have put doubts into some peoples hearts. If I was an honorable person I would ask forgiveness and repent. If that hadiyth is correct as I have presented it then you are in serious trouble. I don't know what you and your kind are doing here 'spreading' the religion of Islaam. Why don't you at least go an learn one book of hadiyth. You seem to know 'Absolutely Nothing.' I am definitely going to put this story in my books and websites. "Pick up a stone to stone a truthful man who speaks the words of the prophet (S+)."