DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Important Advice to workers of Tabligh Jamaat

**cbUDaNFRu** · 09-03-2012, 11:21 PM

Assalamu alaykum

Brother xs11ax;

We have missed here. There are two issues here, one is the booklet by those authors, second is article by mufti desai sahib quoted by these authors.

i apologise if i misunderstood. forgive me.

My first post was on the views of authors in the booklet. Can you please comment on this from that booklet my comments are just the ramblings of a hot headed person with too much time on his hands. even though i give my opinions, they are definitely not worthy of being asked for. there are much more knowledgeable brothers and sisters on this forum who's opinions are much weightier than mine.

on the surface of it, i dont see anything wrong with the comment as long as their is no malice in their intentions. ulama and people all over the world have differences of opinions. as long as the opinions have foundation and are based on the deen then i dont see anything wrong with that. us deobandis really need to move away from our hero worshipping attitude of 'well if hazrat said it then it must be right'. the whole foundation of deoband was built on being progressive even if it meant going against the norm. as deobandis our ulama today should be doing the same. if they did then they would regain the glory of deoband throughout the world. mashallah our ulama gave us so much. may Allah bless them all and fill their graves with noor and grant them the highest stages in jannah.

09-03-2012, 11:21 PM	#16
cbUDaNFRu Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 451 Senior Member	Assalamu alaykum Brother xs11ax; We have missed here. There are two issues here, one is the booklet by those authors, second is article by mufti desai sahib quoted by these authors. i apologise if i misunderstood. forgive me. My first post was on the views of authors in the booklet. Can you please comment on this from that booklet my comments are just the ramblings of a hot headed person with too much time on his hands. even though i give my opinions, they are definitely not worthy of being asked for. there are much more knowledgeable brothers and sisters on this forum who's opinions are much weightier than mine. on the surface of it, i dont see anything wrong with the comment as long as their is no malice in their intentions. ulama and people all over the world have differences of opinions. as long as the opinions have foundation and are based on the deen then i dont see anything wrong with that. us deobandis really need to move away from our hero worshipping attitude of 'well if hazrat said it then it must be right'. the whole foundation of deoband was built on being progressive even if it meant going against the norm. as deobandis our ulama today should be doing the same. if they did then they would regain the glory of deoband throughout the world. mashallah our ulama gave us so much. may Allah bless them all and fill their graves with noor and grant them the highest stages in jannah.
	Quote