DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Praying behind Mamatis is not permissible

**RjkVwPcV** · 09-04-2012, 03:57 AM

Though colonel won't be interested in labeling himself a Mamati but you can read about his stance regarding the life of Sayyidna Muhammad sws after death here , which is in line with the mamatis > http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...sufi-justified

For Maulana Younis Naumani Sahib ( I typed it Manzoor Naumani by error) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmfNq...eature=related

For Abdul Hay luKnavi rahimahullah , there is a thread on SF titled as "Was Imam Abdul Hayy Lucknawi a Hayati or Mamati ?". I hope there are references on that thread or i will have to search for it myself then.

Yaar Dr Saheb,

I think that you will get me beat up :- ) I am getting emails about my Aqeedah left, right and center.

I don’t have time to visit and post on this forum but a long time ago someone brought this to my attention and I ignored it.

Now someone much beloved to me has pointed this out to me and FORCED me to get my password reset, logon and to respond. I have no idea what in the world a “Mamati” actually is and the more I read or watch or listen the more confused I get; I think that it’s some sort of tittle-tattle in Pakistan.

Anyways I am no one important to have to justify my Aqeedah, nevertheless it has been on the web-site for over 10 years, same Aqeedah just updated (text) from time to time, simply put:

It is an accepted fact. Everyone agrees that Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) passed away from this earthly life.
After death, the life is life of Barzakh
This effect of life (Shuhada, Ambiya etc) is only in regards to Barzakh

http://central-mosque.com/index.php/...-upon-him.html

P.S: Any issues and you can email me on the site.

Dr.ati, can you provide proof to your claims that Mawlana Manzoor Numani, Allama Abdul Hayy Lucknawi and Colonel Hardstone are Mamatis? It would be good if Colonel Hardstone himself confirmed/refuted Dr.ati's claim....

I'm sorry, but I can't see anything substantial from Colonel Hardstone to suggest he is a mamaati. I will let him clarify his own position, rather than relying on speculation or weak deductions from his statements.

09-04-2012, 03:57 AM	#37
RjkVwPcV Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 447 Senior Member	Though colonel won't be interested in labeling himself a Mamati but you can read about his stance regarding the life of Sayyidna Muhammad sws after death here , which is in line with the mamatis > http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...sufi-justified For Maulana Younis Naumani Sahib ( I typed it Manzoor Naumani by error) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmfNq...eature=related For Abdul Hay luKnavi rahimahullah , there is a thread on SF titled as "Was Imam Abdul Hayy Lucknawi a Hayati or Mamati ?". I hope there are references on that thread or i will have to search for it myself then. Yaar Dr Saheb, I think that you will get me beat up :- ) I am getting emails about my Aqeedah left, right and center. I don’t have time to visit and post on this forum but a long time ago someone brought this to my attention and I ignored it. Now someone much beloved to me has pointed this out to me and FORCED me to get my password reset, logon and to respond. I have no idea what in the world a “Mamati” actually is and the more I read or watch or listen the more confused I get; I think that it’s some sort of tittle-tattle in Pakistan. Anyways I am no one important to have to justify my Aqeedah, nevertheless it has been on the web-site for over 10 years, same Aqeedah just updated (text) from time to time, simply put: It is an accepted fact. Everyone agrees that Nabi (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) passed away from this earthly life. After death, the life is life of Barzakh This effect of life (Shuhada, Ambiya etc) is only in regards to Barzakh http://central-mosque.com/index.php/...-upon-him.html P.S: Any issues and you can email me on the site. Dr.ati, can you provide proof to your claims that Mawlana Manzoor Numani, Allama Abdul Hayy Lucknawi and Colonel Hardstone are Mamatis? It would be good if Colonel Hardstone himself confirmed/refuted Dr.ati's claim.... I'm sorry, but I can't see anything substantial from Colonel Hardstone to suggest he is a mamaati. I will let him clarify his own position, rather than relying on speculation or weak deductions from his statements.
	Quote